My Dad and I often fought because unlike the other kids in the house I would argue tooth and nail on principals I upheld—like I should be able to go out late because how else will I learn to make choices? There was one particularly heated fight and I went downstairs to my room to blast whatever awful music I listened to at the time and Dad came tearing down the stairs and ripped the entire door off its hinges. I simply glared at him over my book of poetry by Jim Morrison and said, “it was unlocked, jeez.”
Dad was the archetypal blue collar worker. He wore one of his 3 pairs of Wranglers 30 by 32, a pocket shirt of which he had about 7, a brown worn leather belt, and generally a ball cap with some fishing logo or maybe the name of the mine he at which he worked. He changed positions a few times working in the coal mine after starting out in a uranium mine in Douglas, WY. He did a stint in the oil field—his father and two uncles had started “Triple B Energy” in Gillette, WY where they had learned the trade after some semesters at Texas A&M.
Uncle Joe was a self-made chemical engineer or “mud mixer” as its called in the field creating a concoction of chemicals designed to keep the walls of hundreds feet deep drill site from collapsing. Grandpa Loy was more of the talker and business man of the group, in his later life selling cars for a living showing off that Southern sweet talk and charm. My other Great Uncle, Doyle, was less involved living in New Mexico working for NASA for the latter part of his life. I remember him clearly, he was in a wheelchair. When he was younger, he got polio and used plastic straws he kept in his breast pocket to type out his notes on a computer he had configured to fit his shriveled body. I would become so angry when folks looked at him as we tooled around the southwest—he’s smart, don’t you know?!
Some 13 million Americans have managed to move from their blue-collar upbringing to a while-collar world and while class mobility seems to hearken to the American Dream and is generally applauded in the symbolic way—there are lasting consequences. It must have been summer of my sophomore year or so and Dad and I were once again arguing on principal. I had become more proficient at this during my college experience. Disagreements were now an area of growth—I saw these talks as ways to try to open his mind to what I was learning at college—how to think in the grey, how to listen to all sides of a thought and use my own skills of deduction to formulate my world. Dad became more and more frustrated and then eventually said out loud “you are wasting your time, you’ll never make as much as me.” I had to let that statement sink in. He might be right. But is that really why I was getting my Bachelors of Arts in English? To make money?
My parents were able to afford to pay for my room and board the first year of college. I lived in the dorms, Orr Hall, and still look back fondly on those years. I met many life-long friends at the smokers bench by McIntyre Hall where we would meet before meals walking out of the cafeteria smiling with ice cream cones we would feed to the fat, tame squirrels that lived in the tall pines by Fraternity and Sorority Row. I had managed to get a scholarship for 4 years of tuition as one of the top 5% of scholars in the state. I hadn’t hardly applied to any colleges, much less done any scholarships. Senior year was a time of addictions and moving in and out of my house. This scholarship seemed like a fluke but I thought I better try it out—if nothing else than to prove my Dad wrong.
I may or may not make more than my Dad in my life—I feel myself headed there and am painfully aware of being the 10% here in Pagosa Springs—most of my friends in small business or the service industry working 2 or 3 jobs to pay rent in a place they live with several other roommates. Then, there are the white collar retirees who the blue collar folks cater to—a nice restaurant here, $70,000 for a nice new overlook structure painting a portrait of a town that appreciates finer architecture and place where Texans might buy your art. But, mobility here is highly unlikely. The college nearby, Fort Lewis, has gained the name “Fort Leisure” and doles out liberal arts and education degrees with the promise of Straddler status—rising from the woods of Southwest Colorado to get a corporate job on the Front Range. I don’t know if that even happens. The salary may increase with education, but us blue collar folks may never speak the language of the privileged.
I feel a real sense of fragmentation sometimes. Here I am, with my Masters of Science, which means something to me and meant something in higher education—the industry I recently vacated to try my hand at professional counseling. I try to avoid the inevitable “when did you get to Pagosa, what do you do” talks because I feel hyper-aware of my self-imposed status. I can hardly speak the nuances of a while collar existence but my blue collar roots seems to create suspicion as well. I usually rely on the old geographical class mobility—oh I’m from Wyoming I’m a good ol’ boy (girl). But I know secretly that if I comment on politics in a way that is non-polarizing—I might be shunned. I’m not quite the liberal retiree speaking of Trumps evil, but I’m also not the conservative leaning fishing guide still obsessed with land ownership as another vehicle of hopping social classes. An imposter in both worlds.
I didn’t walk in graduation for either my bachelors or my masters. I didn’t know if my family would come. And I certainly didn’t feel that they knew what I had accomplished. From the outside, it may have looked like I spent 4 years drinking and reading poetry and then 2 years in my masters learning the language of empathy which I’m sure most homemakers like my Mom would attest is something that can be done in child-rearing. I was the first in the family (in this generation) to achieve both degrees with a first cousin obtaining her law degree from Tulane. We had done it. But there are still certain things I won’t talk about if I ever were to visit Texas again and hit up the family reunion. I won’t share my postmodern theories of classism, I won’t speak at length about racism, hegemony, or eco-feminism which I still use as a framework to view the world. But these are the topics that set me apart and let me mingle with the white collar folks of academia. They just want brilliance and it can come from many different roots.
I think my Dad and I could argue because of the blue-collar existence. We weren’t too worried about keeping up appearances. I never remember one BBQ or dinner party hosted at my parents house. My Dad has the same 3 piece suit he wore to church, weddings, funerals. My Dad worked 12 hours shifts at the coal mine toward the end of his life, added to a 3 hour commute to get the mine 70 miles away. When I was younger he would come home with black-coal eyeliner and his fingers dirty making me think he actually dug coal for a living. Later, he would shower at the mine and the only evidence of hard labor was his pink-red eyes, slanted from the tiring physical work he had been doing his whole life. A damn hard worker. And so I still continue to work hard and grapple with my straddle status. I have retirement, insurance, benefits. But I still try to remember my roots and bear the load of paying for most of my education. In theory I may have crossed social classes but in reality I will pay for my status forever.
“Social class counts at the office, even though nobody likes to admit it. Ultimately, corporate norms are based on middle- and upper-class values, business types say. From an early age, middle-class people learn how to get along, using diplomacy, nuance, and politics to grab what they need. It is as though they are following a set of rules laid out in a manual that blue-collar families never have the chance to read.”
-Alfre Lubrano, Limbo: Blue Collar Roots, White Collar Dreams